|
While the sun has
surely begun to set on 16-bit/44.1kHz digital, it may be some time
before night truly befalls the much maligned compact disc. As both
high-end manufacturers and consumers impatiently await the outcome of
what is sure to become a bloody battle between long word-length, high
sample-rate digital formats, consumer digital audio will likely
maintain the status quo for the foreseeable future.
So reasons companies
like England's Naim Audio (whose most recent offering, the CD 3.5,
will be the subject of an upcoming review) and Sweden's Copland, two
leaders of the European conservative movement who have clearly (and,
some would argue, quite wisely) taken a wait-and-see attitude to
digital's next generation. No, Copland's latest digital entry, the CDA
266, is not super-CD-ready, nor can it be upgraded to such status.
What it is, though, is a relatively affordable single-box CD player,
whose sonic performance might just be sufficiently good to carry us
into the second act of digital audio's critically unacclaimed debut.
Description With
its austere, yet elegant, Swedish styling, the Copland CDA 266 is one
of the most aesthetically pleasing CD players to pass through my
listening room. While still of rather sizable dimension (its 16 ½"
wide x 3 ¾" high x 15" deep enclosure dwarfing that of
the low-profile Naim CD 3.5), the CDA 266 is considerably smaller than
Copland's earlier single-box player, the CDA 288.
The center of the CDA
266's silver brushed aluminum faceplate is occupied by a
friction-defying CD drawer and a green digital display, upon which the
standard array of information (track number, track timing, etc.) is
made available. To the left and right of center are one round machined
aluminum knob each for powering the unit on and off and for accessing
the player's operational functions (play, pause, track skip forward,
and track skip backward) respectively. Located between the display and
the right control knob is a diminutive silver button labeled 'open'
which, when depressed once, causes the CD drawer to be opened and,
when pressed twice in rapid succession, stops the player. Finally, to
the left of the display (and to the right of the left control knob)
exists a small green LED which illuminates to indicate activation of
the onboard HDCD decoding circuitry. Supporting the CDA 266 are four
fairly substantial isolation feet, each of whose perimeter is finished
in faceplate-matching silver.
The rear of the CDA 266
is as unadorned as its front, offering nothing more than a detachable
AC power cord, a pair of gold-plated RCA outputs, and a coaxial
digital output for those few who choose to partner the player with an
outboard digital processor. A toggle switch is provided to switch off
the digital output when not in use.
Digital-to-analogue
conversion is handled by dual Burr-Brown PCM 63P 20-bit 8X
oversampling DACs, and digital filtering is performed by the
now-ubiquitous PMD-100 HDCD decoder/filter from Pacific Microsonics.
The transport is manufactured by Sony and features an integral sprung
suspension (no, CD players are not impervious to the ills of
structure and air-borne vibration). Both the analogue stage and power
supply have been given special attention by Copland, the former
featuring complementary class 'A' topology, the latter being shielded
both statically and magnetically from the player's delicate
electronics.
Accompanying the CDA
266 is a handsome full-function remote control (fashioned from
plastic), providing myriad control and programming features
unavailable from the front panel. The remote also provides the ability
to dim the player's display to two different levels of brightness or
to shut it off entirely, the latter setting having distinctly positive
sonic implications described below.
While offering a
somewhat unique ergonomic experience (the user is required to push,
rather than turn, the right control knob to activate the player's
'play' mode, for example), the CDA 266 is a model of both form and
function, combining elegant styling with flawless mechanical
operation.
Associated
Components
Digital:
Theta Data Basic II transport and DS Pro Progeny DAC, Naim CD 3.5
CD Player. Preamplifier:
Audible Illusions Modulus 3A with John Curl designed gold MC phono
board Power
Amplifier: Celeste Moon W-5
Loudspeakers: ProAc Studio 150, Anthony Gallo Acoustics
Nucleus Solo Cables:
D Lin Audio Silver Bullets 4.0 interconnects, Transparent
Audio MusicWave Plus loudspeaker cables.
Accessories: Echo Busters room treatment products, Target
equipment stands, Black Diamond Racing Mk.III and Mk.IV Pyramid
Cones, 15A dedicated AC outlets. |
Listening I
must confess that I found the Copland CDA 266 CD player to be
something of an enigma. There were some aspects of its performance
which heralded it as a harbinger of digital's future, for if this is
what could be done with an arguably inadequate digital specification,
then what of 24-bits and 96kHz? Other aspects of its performance,
however, transported me back to the digital days of yore. The 266's
somewhat two steps forward, no steps back, perspective, coupled with
an upper midrange and lower treble which could, at times, cross that
fine line from detailed and up-front to slightly aggressive and
fatiguing, left me pining on more than one occasion for the more
refined presentation of my two-box reference. On less fortunate
recordings, the upper registers of the female voice and high strings
took on a touch of edge and glare, and vocal sssssibilance was
slightly exaggerated.
The 266's forward
presentation did not always prove off-putting, however, working to
good effect on intimate lounge material such as Diana Krall's superb
Love Scenes (Impulse! IMPSD 234), on which each of Ms. Krall's
vocal inflections and breathy exhalations were portrayed vividly (as
was the obtrusive sound of the session engineer fading Krall's
microphone in and out throughout I Don't Stand a Ghost of a Chance
with You). While placed in a rather more dominant position than
usual by the CDA 266, Michael Laird's trumpet sounded simply splendid
on The Trumpet Shall Sound from Handel's Messiah (Archiv 423
630-2), each detail of his superb performance being bathed in a most
illuminating light. Curiously, the CDA 266's slight treble spit and
splash could be partially, though not entirely, ameliorated by
switching off its front-panel display, indicating that noise from the
display's electronics was finding its way into the player's sensitive
audio circuitry. I suggest that anyone wishing to hear the full
measure of the CDA 266 audition it with its display switched off.
Enough criticism, what
of the 266's plentiful positives? In stark contrast to the ghastly
devices of digital's embryonic period, the CDA 266 presented a
soundstage full of dimension at all gradations of volume. Even during
the most intense orchestral eruptions, the CDA 266 refused to reduce
the soundstage to two-dimensions. The depth and breadth of the hall
captured on the glorious Harmonia Mundi recording of Brahms' Sacred
Choral Works (HM 901591), was well communicated by the CDA 266,
the image of the Rias-Kammerchor being presented well behind the plane
of the loudspeakers. On well-engineered orchestral discs, soundstage
transparency was exemplary, with the most distant reaches of the stage
being well delineated.
The CDA 266's ability
to present a precisely focused image of the soundstage, with
instruments and performers occupying well-defined spatial positions,
was good, if somewhat less developed than that of other, admittedly
more expensive, players (a precisely defined spatial image is not, as
some would argue, merely an artifact of the recording process, but is
readily heard in the concert hall). Using an artistic metaphor, images
rendered by the CDA 266 were more akin to those of the impressionistic
than realist periods.
The 266's upper octaves
were full of air, sparkle and life, bearing little likeness to the dry
chalky picture painted by lesser digital devices. The percussive
sounds of cymbals, tambourines, and triangles, as heard on a diversity
of discs including Eric Clapton's Unplugged (Reprise 45024),
Strunz and Farah's Americas (Mesa R2 79041), and Chabrier's
España (Mercury Living Presence 434 303-2), were
rendered with a considerable measure of the clarity and speed of their
live counterparts. Counter-balancing the CDA 266's extended top-end
was a full, taut bottom, with enough power and impact to bring life to
the fff bass
drum strokes of Rachmaninoff's Symphonic Dances (Telarc
CD-80331), and the requisite articulation to dissect the unison double
bass lines of Splanky from Christian McBride's Gettin' To
It (Verve 314 523 989-2). The CDA 266's low-octave
performance did, in fact, prove the equal of the considerably more
expensive Theta Data Basic II/DS Pro Progeny combination, and bettered
that of the similarly priced (and superbly musical) Naim CD 3.5 -
impressive indeed.
Aside from its slight
grain and glare in the upper midrange, I found much to admire in the
CDA 266's rendering of the human voice. En masse voices, in
particular, fared especially well. The choral sections of Since by
Man Came Death, from Handel's Messiah, and Brahms' Sacred
Choral Music, were notable for their extraordinary combination of
power, delicacy, and nuance - qualities rarely heard in unison from
digital playback. Midrange articulation was another hallmark of the
CDA 266's performance. Although singing as a group, the large choral
forces on both the Handel and Brahms discs could be heard to consist
of singular voices, each one readily discernible within the vocal mélange.
Perhaps owing to its
transient speed and extended upper octaves, the CDA 266 was one of the
more energetic and lively players to come my way. The hard-edged
squawks of '60s Coltrane (Crescent, Impulse! IMPD-200) blared
their way naturally into the listening room, without the softening or
rounding reminiscent of more forgiving, but less transparent, devices.
Hard bop, fast-moving modern jazz,
up-tempo World Music, and driving rock all proved rhythmically
involving and thoroughly electrifying, owing to the CDA 266's brisk
transient response and faithful portrayal of pace and timing. The Naim
CD 3.5, in comparison, sounded somewhat slow and subdued - rather
surprising considering this British company's rhythm-centric design
philosophy.
Conclusion As
audiophiles await the dawn of the next digital age, promising less
pain and more Hertz, they must content themselves with today's rather
flawed, albeit much improved, playback medium. Making the wait that
much more palatable are players like the Copland CDA 266. Although the
CDA 266 does exhibit vestiges of digital's dog days (namely, a
somewhat forward presentation with a bit of grain and glare throughout
portions of the upper midrange and lower treble), it is, on the whole,
a very musically satisfying device. Of course, financial
considerations aside, a more refined CD playback system could
certainly be acquired. But while the standard-makers and risk-takers
define the digital audio carriers of the future, the Copland CDA 266
may be just the thing to while away the time in peace and harmony.
|